"McCabe & Mrs. Miller" as Number One? I do not even have to look at the rest to know this list is worthless. A London web-zine talking about westerns and giving this films its top spot is as worthy as me saying that "Peter Pan" is the best movie portrayal of Victorian Era England.
I agree on McClintock, it should be up there. What about The Cheyenne Social Club? It's a top 50 for sure. Not to lean too heavily on The Duke, but I didn't see El Dorado on there...did I miss it? I thought James Caan was great in that movie!
Pin it! 
3 comments
Login to comment →
LSUTigersFan 12 years, 2 months ago
"McCabe & Mrs. Miller" as Number One? I do not even have to look at the rest to know this list is worthless. A London web-zine talking about westerns and giving this films its top spot is as worthy as me saying that "Peter Pan" is the best movie portrayal of Victorian Era England.
Reply
pduffie 12 years, 2 months ago
I am disgusted by this list. Rio Bravo is top ten. McClintock is top ten. Tombstone is top ten. Just terrible
Reply
awayne 12 years, 2 months ago
I agree on McClintock, it should be up there. What about The Cheyenne Social Club? It's a top 50 for sure. Not to lean too heavily on The Duke, but I didn't see El Dorado on there...did I miss it? I thought James Caan was great in that movie!
Reply